The Balanced Diet: Roasted Cherry Tomato Puttanesca

Growing up, my mom rarely made pasta for dinner. She’s been eating gluten-free for as long as I can remember, and back in the days before Whole Foods, you were hard-pressed to find any sort of decent wheat-free spaghetti substitute that didn’t disintegrate upon impact with boiling water.

So it wasn’t until after I fled the nest that I learned how to make a basic pasta sauce. In college, a 28-ounce can of Muir Glen was my lifeline. (At least, on days when I wasn’t eating pizza for breakfast, lunch, and dinner and wondering why half my tops looked like fat-guy-in-a-little-coat). I was always kind of a purest with my red sauce. Some might even say I was kind of a bore. But I could eat tomato-basil (on spaghetti or Antonio’s pizza) 7 days a week.

Though I love any food-related word that translates to slut, I never really got down with Puttanesca. Perhaps it was the anchovies. But more likely, it was just the idea of all those funky ingredients coming together in one big bitch-slap to your palette. Until recently, my mother never really cooked with olives or capers. But since he became a pescatarian, my dad is a devout caper convert. If there are capers in a dish, there’s a 98 percent chance he’ll think it’s the best thing he’s ever tasted. Kind of like my mother with mayonnaise and me with avocado.

I do have one distinct puttanesca memory, however. It comes by way of my Aunt Barbara and Uncle Denny, back when my summers on Martha’s Vineyard were a time when the whole family gathering under one roof, and the most controversial area became the kitchen. Yes, these were the days of Phoebe’s Restaurant. And yes, that added to the controversy. There were a lot of dominant blood-related cooks around the house, and their food tastes often got along even less well than they did.

I’m not sure how old I was, but I remember coming back to the big house one night during a gloomy summer storm and Barbara and Denny had made dinner for themselves and my cousins, who were much older, smarter, and more mature than I was (well, am). My mother likely turned her nose up and pushed some stray tomato cores aside to make herself a salad. But I ended up joining them and eating my first bowl of spaghetti puttanesca. I’m sure I removed the olives and capers to the side of my plate with expert operation-style precision. But I remember loving the flavors nonetheless.

I’m back on Martha’s Vineyard now for the first time this summer. The big house where my family used to gather was torn down in the fall, and the site contains the first stages of the McMansion the new owners are erecting. Truly the end of an era.

Luckily, my parents managed to buy the small cottage my grandparents built next door, and though they’ve improved it drastically from the rather schizo layout that existed prior, it still contains many memories from the days of puttanesca. It also has a new and very luxurious kitchen, which, if my mom’s siblings ever came to stay, could provide room for all the dominant blood-related cooks in the house – starting with my mother and me!

It was raining on the island this week and I decided to reach into my memory arsenal to reinvent this neglected classic dish. I used some fresh cherry tomatoes from the Farmer’s Market and concentrated all those funky flavors in the oven instead of on the stove. If you have a break from the summer heat wave, a big bowl of sweet and briny puttanesca sauce is the perfect meal for a crisp summer night, capers, olives, memories and all.

Eat up!




Roasted Cherry Tomato Puttanesca

Serving Size: Makes 4 servings

This sauce is excellent in its traditional incarnation: swirled with spaghetti. Since you're using fresh tomatoes, it's more of a ragu than a sauce that clings to ever strand of pasta. But regardless, slutty noodles never tasted better. The briny olives and capers also make it a great condiment for seafood. I actually added some shrimp to the pan and roasted them in the sauce for another 10 minutes before tossing the whole luscious mess with my slightly less luscious quinoa pasta. Perfection.


  • 2 pints cherry tomatoes, halved
  • ¼ cup roughly chopped Kalamata olives
  • ¼ cup capers
  • 1 anchovy fillet, minced
  • 2 garlic cloves, thinly sliced
  • 2 shallots, thinly sliced
  • 1 tablespoon chopped fresh oregano
  • 2 teaspoons sugar
  • ½ teaspoon salt
  • ½ teaspoon red pepper flakes
  • 3 tablespoons olive oil
  • 2 tablespoons finely chopped fresh parsley


  1. Preheat the oven to 425 degrees F.
  2. Combine all the ingredients except for the parsley in a medium mixing bowl and toss to combine.
  3. Spread the tomato mixture in an even layer in a 12-inch cast iron skillet or a 9 x 13 baking dish. Bake for 30 minutes, until the tomatoes are caramelized and their juices have mingled nicely with the briny olives and capers.
  4. To serve, add the fresh parsley and a heap of cooked spaghetti to the pan and toss to combine. Drizzle with olive oil and mangia! Alternatively, you can store the sauce for later or use it as a topping for fish or shrimp.

instagram  If you make this, share a photo and tag me @PhoebeLapine #feedmephoebe - I would love to see it!

This post is brought to you, along with many other fabulous tomato recipes, as part of Food Network Summerfest. Check out the other participating sites below!

Cooking With Elise: Fresh Tomato Sauce
Jeanette’s Healthy Living: Tomato Gazpacho Salsa
Napa Farmhouse 1885: Tomato Cobbler Anyone?
Virtually Homemade: Spaghetti With Tomatoes, Prosciutto and Fresh Corn
What’s Gaby Cooking: Chicken Kebabs With Romesco Sauce
Big Girls, Small Kitchen: Salmon Spaghetti With Plum Tomatoes and Avocado
Feed Me Phoebe: Roasted Fresh Tomato Puttanesca Sauce
Chez Us: Easy Tomato Tart
Made By Michelle: Tomato and Pesto Pizza
Ingredients, Inc.: Lighter Fried Green Tomatoes
Delicious Lean: Creamy Light Tuna Salad Stuffed Tomatoes
Daily*Dishin: Spicy Tomato-Tomatillo Chicken Tenders
From My Corner of Saratoga: Tomato Jam
Dishin & Dishes: Tomato Zucchini Frittata
And Love It Too: Roasted Garlic, Basil and Tomato Paleo Tart
Healthy Eats: The Fresh-for-Once Tomato
Sweet Life Bake: Pico de Gallo
Zaika Zabardast: Grilled Tofu and Sun-Dried Tomato Pesto Sandwich
Thursday Night Dinner: Tomato and Watermelon Salad
Cooking Channel: How to Prepare Summer Tomatoes
FN Dish: Tomatoes Go Beyond Salads


Comment23 Share This!

23 Responses to The Balanced Diet: Roasted Cherry Tomato Puttanesca

  1. Pingback: Fresh Tomato Sauce

  2. Pingback: Ingredients, Inc.Lighter Fried Green Tomatoes

  3. Pingback: Pico de Gallo | Sweet Life

  4. Pingback: Heirloom Tomato Romesco Sauce Recipe

  5. Pingback: Gazpacho Salsa Recipe - Food Network Summer Fest - Jeanette's Healthy Living

  6. Pingback: Tomato and Pesto Pizza

  7. Chef Chuck says:

    I love those cherry tomatoes !
    This is a wonderful blend…
    Thank you for sharing 😉

  8. Pingback: Grilled tofu and sun dried tomato pesto Sandwich! « Zaika Zabardast

  9. Jeanette says:

    My kids love Puttanesca Sauce – I’m sure they’d love this version using roasted tomatoes!

  10. Frankie says:

    I like that you used the anchovy as a vague accent – other puttanescas I’ve tried smelled too fishy (kind of like sluts)

  11. Pingback: Feeding Friends: Grilled Flank Steak with Gazpacho Sauce | Feed Me Phoebe

  12. Pingback: Easy Summer Tomato Tart » Chez Us

  13. Bob says:

    Saw the recipe with the photo. There appears to be onions(shallots?) in the pic but are not listed in the ingredients. Is it an option?

    • Hi Bob – indeed! Your eyes must have played tricks on you. There are 2 shallots, thinly sliced, listed in the ingredients. You can definitely use onion (finely chopped) instead if you like! Best, Phoebe

  14. Pingback: Feeding Friends: Roasted Cauliflower and Fennel Salad with Endive and Radicchio | Feed Me Phoebe

  15. Alan says:

    Why on earth don’t you provide a print function so one can print recipe without printing the flipping pictures too?

    • Hi Alan, The more recent recipes do have a print function via ziplist. I’m in the process of converting my archives. I have over 350 recipes, so as you can imagine, it takes time. Thank you for being so patient and understanding.

  16. Pingback: Same Ingredients, Two Recipes - It's Caprese Day at The Heritage Cook! - The Heritage Cook ®

  17. Pingback: Roasted Garlic, Basil and Tomato Paleo Tart

  18. Pingback: How-To Cook for a Low FODMAP Diet - Feed Me Phoebe

  19. Pingback: A Guide to Healthy Seafood: The Best Fish to Eat & How to Cook Them

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *