This baked brisket recipe with onions and tomatoes is perfect for any Jewish holiday, but it has been at the center of our Passover table for generations. The beef gets stuffed with whole garlic cloves then cooked low and slow in the oven with a topping of caramelized onions. It is truly the best brisket you will ever eat.
When we were in the peak of COVID, we gathered for Seder on zoom. Besides my family, the element I missed most was the Passover brisket, which seemed silly to make for just two people.
My Aunt Jennifer is responsible for most of my formative memories of brisket, and most of my positive experiences with Passover. The highlights of the family meal were always the many chairs added year after year to make up for the new additions to the table; my undefeated record with the afikomen; cousin Holly’s Chocolate Chip Macaroons; and my aunt’s brisket, which we would all be hankering for after two hours of bitter herbs, hard-boiled eggs, and plagues.
Passover has always been one of my favorite Jewish holidays, but in college, I couldn’t always make it back to CT to Aunt Jenn’s. My junior year, I was stuck at school and decided to host a seder of my own. My friend Jamie procured the prayer books and plenty of matzoh. Jillian made her mother’s potatoes. And I provided the brisket.
It felt a little strange to deviate from my aunt’s famous dish, but I managed to fill the buffet table with a respectable, if not, entirely perfect, slab of soft, slow-cooked meat thanks to the goyim influence of Mr. Emeril Lagasse.
I thought this was the perfect opportunity to resurrect my recipe that was once a staple on my old blog, Big Girls Small Kitchen (hard to believe that and my first cookbook were published over 10 years ago!).
If you caught last week’s post, then you know I’m on a bit of a roll with cooking my way through my own archives from a decade ago. This recipe certainly held up, though SIBO Amigos will gawk at the ingredient list—I certainly haven’t used this much onion and garlic in a WHILE!
My husband was also thrilled to see ketchup back in the fridge. I used an organic brand and worried that without the chemicals, it would be missing that je ne sais quoi. But luckily it held up. Because I’m more sensitive to sugar now, I cut back on the added amount. And if I made it again, I might even experiment with eliminating it entirely and seeing what the ketchup does on its own.
The result is the best Passover brisket you will ever eat: moist, perfectly tangy, and sweet with a slight kick. Stuffing the meat with garlic cloves is my favorite part. This was the technique inspired by Emeril. They melt completely away by the end but make the sauce and meat that much more flavorful.
What is the best pan to cook this brisket?
Many of the questions I get about this recipe is what do I put such a large piece of brisket in to cook? Since this recipe is made completely in the oven, it is pretty versatile: just use whatever oven-proof baking dish or pan can accommodate a 5 pound brisket.
In these images, my brisket is slightly smaller, so I used an oval Dutch oven. I have used metal roasting pans or baking dishes, and in a pinch, a 9×13 Pyrex pan. The reason glass isn’t my preferred vehicle is that I once shattered a Pyrex making this exact brisket! If you’re going this route, just make sure that your beef stock isn’t cold straight from the fridge when you pour it into the hot pan. A big difference in temperature could cause the glass to implode. I’ve made a note of this in the instructions!
5 Star Reader Review
“Wow this really was the best Passover brisket! My whole family proclaimed that it was the best they’d ever had. I had never seared something in the oven in a Dutch oven. It turned out absolutely fork tender and perfect. 10/10 would recommend this recipe and method. Thank you!”—Taylor
What if my brisket is bigger than 5 pounds?
If you’re making this Passover brisket for a larger crowd, you don’t necessarily need to double the recipe. So long as your piece of meat still fits within one pan, it will have the same cook time and not need additional stock and seasonings.
If on the other hand you are making TWO 5-pound briskets in two separate baking dishes, you will want to double the recipe.
The brisket should be slice-able but the meat should be tender enough that you don’t need a knife to cut it at the table. The marbling should be easily broken with the side of your fork. If you feel your brisket slices are too tough, have no fear: you can just toss the whole thing back in the oven! The meat is very forgiving.
If you’re looking for more Passover recipes to round out the Seder table, I have plenty of gluten-free desserts in my archives that fit the bill. You can’t go wrong with flourless peanut butter cookies!
Read on for the best Passover brisket recipe! Until next year in Jerusalem…or at least, inside our relative’s house.
With health and hedonism,
The Best Passover Brisket
- Preheat the oven to 500°F.
- Place the brisket on a work surface. If the fat cap is on the thicker side (1/2 inch) trip off a little of the fat, leaving an even 1/4 -inch layer.
- Using a paring knife, make vertical incisions in the meat and shove a piece of garlic into each. Do this until the meat is stuffed with garlic all over. Season both sides with salt and pepper and place the brisket in a large braiser, Dutch oven or rimmed baking dish (preferably metal) starting with the fat cap facing up and brown it in the oven, about 10 minutes per side.
- Remove the pan from the oven, and pour in the beef stock (NOTE: if you are using a pyrex dish, wait a few minutes for the pan to acclimate to room temperature so it does not shatter.). Turn the oven down to 350 degrees, cover the dish with a lid or foil, and cook in the oven for 1 hour.
- In the meantime, heat 1 tablespoon of olive oil over medium-low heat in a large skillet. Add the onions and sauté, stirring every once in a while, until soft and caramelized, about 30 minutes.
- Remove the meat from the oven, and add the ketchup, sugar, paprika, smoked paprika, cayenne, thyme or rosemary, and bay leaves to the pan. Using a fork, whisk everything together with the beef stock. Arrange the caramelized onions on top of the meat. Cover the pan again with the lid or foil, and return it to the oven for 2-3 hours. NOTE: if you want to be able to cut the brisket into slices, take it out at 2 hours. If you want it to be falling apart, more along the lines of a pulled brisket, keep it in for the full 3.
- Remove the meat from the oven, and transfer it to a cutting board. Slice the brisket against the grain into slices. Return the meat to the sauce and serve, or store in the fridge overnight–the brisket can be made a day or two in advance.